059 - Small-Pox and Vaccination in the Light of Modern Knowledge

In this post, James McIntosh reviews some things about smallpox and vaccination against it.

Smallpox has been known to humanity since the 10th century, and to Europe since the 16th. People confused it with measles at first, and so thought it fairly mild, until it killed some royalty. Mostly it was only fatal in children (not that that's a good thing); 90% of deaths in epidemics were in children under 5. Mortality in people who caught it was typically 30-50%, which is very high for an infectious disease. And virulence seemed to be increasing through the 18th century, so people were excited about immunization.

Somewhat later, virulence seemed to shift toward older people and decrease over all, probably because of immunization, but also because another variety of the disease seemed to appear: called alastrim, or variola minor, the disease it causes is much milder than the original, even though they are almost histologically and serologically indistinguishable. Alastrim doesn't seem to make vaccination impossible (which it might if it induced an adequate immune response itself), but vaccination does prevent alastrim. But it did not replace smallpox, which still caused epidemics just as serious as before.

Regarding smallpox itself, McIntosh was uncertain whether Edward Jenner's original virus was really cowpox (vaccinia) or was rather an infection of cows with smallpox. I haven't read anything so far that does make a clear distinction between these possibilities. But in either case, it seemed safer than the practice at the time, which was called variolation: inoculating people with a little smallpox, which would cause disease but not as much as if they caught the disease unintentionally, and would induce good immunity. That practice sometimes didn't work out well, as you might expect.

So when Jenner's vaccination (from vaccinia) came along, the practice spread widely because it was safer and milder but just as good immunity-wise. Not completely safe though, as I mentioned before (040): post-vaccinal encephalitis was a serious side effect from vaccination, in which the immune system seemed to attack the nervous system, often causing paralysis and/or death. The incidence of this was 1 in 3555 recipients, or 1 in 31531 in children under 2, which isn't very many, but a lot more than would be preferable. McIntosh had some suggestions for avoiding this, but none he was very certain about: treating cases with serum from vaccinated people, maybe, or preventing it entirely by weakening the virus before vaccinating; this latter had the risk that it might be too weak to induce a good immune response. McIntosh thought it should be possible to standardize and minimize the dose as much as possible to let the body respond to it before it spread too much. I wonder how successful any attempts at that might have been.

Citation: Mcintosh, J. Small-Pox and Vaccination in the Light of Modern Knowledge. The Lancet 215, 618–621 (1930).